Getting reliable drinking water in the outdoor can be a tricky task. Even when you are surrounded by crystal clear lakes with no-one around you, the water could be contaminated with harmful bacteria and viruses. When traveling in less developed countries, the chances are likely that sometimes also tap water is contaminated. Even when the water looks clear, that doesn’t mean it is clean.
There is a wide range of water treatment systems out there that are specifically developed for outdoor activities and traveling. They all have their own advantages and disadvantages.This article provides a complete overview of the different water treatment methods and when to use them.
Water filtration and water purification
Most people talk about water filters when talking about water treatment. But water treatment can be classified in water filters and water purifiers. They are two different things. In general, water filters remove particles and protect against bacteria and protozoa (parasites). While water purifiers protect against bacteria, protozoa ánd viruses.
Water filters work by blocking passage of particles, protozoa and bacteria – basically anything larger than 2 micron. Water filters can not remove viruses, since viruses are very small (1000 times smaller than bacteria) and can slip through water filters. Water purifiers therefore often use other techniques such as ultraviolet light, chemicals, heat or ultra-filtration to eliminate waterborne viruses.
Do I need a water filter or a water purifier for outdoor activities?
Which water treatment you need, comes down to one question. Should you worry about viruses or not? In remote areas, high up in the mountains for instance, the risk that water is contaminated with harmful viruses is relatively low. How does that work?
In general, protozoa and bacteria infect and affect both animals and humans alike. They are transmitted to water sources by human and animal waste. Animals and humans drinking from this source will both be infected with these protozoa and bacteria.
In contrast, viruses are species-specific. Therefore, viruses that affect humans are transmitted by human waste alone. Not via animal waste. Meaning, only viruses from human waste are harmful to humans.
As a rule of thumb you could use the following.
In remote areas with few people around water requires filtration. There, the biggest concerns are ‘dirty’ water (silt and debris), bacteria and protozoa, not so much viruses.
Traveling in less developed countries with poor sanitation, the chances that tap water are contaminated with harmful viruses increases and water purification is recommended.
In areas where human waste is present, a popular wild camping spot near a stream for instance, water needs both filtration and purification. There, the concerns are ‘dirty’ water (particles, bacteria and protozoa) and viruses.
What are different outdoor water filters and water purifiers capable of?
The next part is a bit technical, but hopefully it will shed some light on the capabilities of the 5 main water treatment methods: filtering, UV-light, chemical treatment, heat and ultra filtration. What do they remove? And under which circumstances do they work?
|Large particles||Protozoa||Bacteria||Viruses||Multicellular parasites||Heavy metals|
|Microfilter||yes||yes||yes||no||yes||only with active carbon|
|Chemical treatment (tablets/ drops)||no||not all of them||yes||yes||no||no|
|Ultra filtration (0.02)||yes||yes||yes||yes||yes||only with active carbon|
Most water filters these days have a hollow fiber membrane water filter. Hundreds of small straws bundled together to create a filter. A water filter needs a pore size of minimum 2 microns to remove bacteria and protozoa. If the pore size is bigger, bacteria can slip through. Water filters are effective in both clear and highly turbid water. Water filters however do not protect against viruses.
Water purification methods such as UV light, water purification tablets or simply boiling the water all inactivate bacteria, protozoa and viruses. But these water purification methods all have one thing in common. It doesn’t remove anything from the water. If the water has a brown color, or contains silt it will still be brown and contains the silt after purification. When looking in more detail to what water purifiers are capable of, you will see some flaws. They do not always protect against all protozoa and parasites.
Water purification: chemical treatment
Water purification tablets or drops have been used for decades. They do not always provide 100% protection against all protozoa (cryptosporidium) or larger parasites (worms). Water purification tablets are less effective in cloudy water. For back country use it is recommended to use ‘clear’ water or pre-filter the water before using them. Most tablets require a waiting period, usually 30 minutes but up to 4 hours.
Water purification: UV light
Ultraviolet light treatments are effective against bacteria, protozoa and viruses. And unlike most chemicals, they don’t give a particular taste to the water.
UV light treatment may sound high tech, but it it is only effective in clear water. If the water is silty, muddy or discolored, particles in the water can shield the microbes from the light’s effects. Also multicellular parasites (worms) can survive the UV light treatment. For back country use it is recommended to find a ‘clear’ water source or pre-filter the water before using UV light.
As you can see both tablets, drops or UV light all work better when it’s combined with a filter, in particular in the outdoor when water can be cloudy.
Water purification: Boiling
Boiling is one of the most effective ways to purify water. It kills all pathogens and requires simply the heating of water for one minute, or 3 minutes above 2000 m. Even when water is murky or cloudy.
Water purification: Ultra- filtration
Ultra-filtration is the only ‘stand-alone system’ to remove particulates, protozoa, bacteria, worms ánd viruses. Ultra-filtration works the same as a water filter. With a 100 times smaller pore size of 0.02 micron, it also blocks passage of viruses. Although the name would suggest we are talking about water filtration, ultra- filtration falls under the category ‘water purifier’, because it also protects against viruses. Sounds perfect right? The downside of ultra filtration systems is that they are filtering to such a small pore size, they tend to clog quickly. They have a relative short life span, making it less ideal for longer periods of traveling.
Remove heavy metals for water
Water can also be contaminated with heavy metals (copper, lead, arsenic, mercury). But note that most water filters and water purifiers do NOT remove heavy metals. The focus of water filters and water purifiers is to remove microorganisms that could cause immediate harm. Heavy metals are generally only harmful after repeated and long term exposure.
If you still want to reduce the level of heavy metals in your drinking water you should opt for a water filter that contains active carbon. Active carbon adsorbs heavy metals, but there is a lot of uncertainty to what extend these filters remove heavy metals.
Which water treatment should I use in which situation?
Based on the countries you are traveling, and the main water source you get your water from, you might be interested in only a water filter, only a water purifier or a combination of both. Let’s have a look at a few examples.
Situation 1: Get water from a mountain stream in Norway
- Use a water filter. You want to remove possible particles, bacteria and protozoa. Harmful viruses are of less concern, the next village is 40 kilometer away.
Situation 2: Fill my water bottles from a water tap in a city in Colombia
- Use a water purifier (tablets, drops, UV SteriPen) or boil the water before drinking it. The water from the tap looks clear, so there is no need to remove particles. But the overall sanitation infrastructure is not well developed. You want to eliminate possible bacteria, parasites and viruses.
Situation 3: Get water from a stream close to a mining village in Peru.
- Use a combination of a water filter and water purifier. First use the water filter to remove the sediment. This also removes possible protozoa and bacteria. Next, use a water purifier to kill possible viruses.
- The water is possibly contaminated with heavy metals from the mines. It is better to not use water in the vicinity of the mine. However, because you are only passing through the region with short potential exposure to heavy metal contaminants, you shouldn’t be too worried about it. Sadly, the people that live there and drink contaminated water day in day out for a long period of time are the one at risk to get serious health effects.
Examples of outdoor water filters and water purifiers
Water filters and water purifiers come in many sizes and forms. As it is an essential piece of equipment for outdoor life, we always opt for proven quality. These brands stand out. MSR and Sawyer. Here are three examples of high quality outdoor water filters and water purifiers resp.:
Outdoor water filters
- MSR Autoflow Gravity Filter 2 and 4 liters
Very convenient to filter large amount of water. You fill the ‘dirty water bag’, attach the hose with the filter element, and attach an Ortlieb clean water bag at the end of the hose. Within 15 minutes you have filtered up to four liters. The best thing is, you can leave it and it does the work for you. In the meantime, you pitch the tent or make a cup of coffee. It is a little bit heavier and bulkier than the other filters.
- MSR trailshot micro filter
Very convenient as it is small and lightweight. You do need a lot of squeezing to filter several liters. But its fantastic if you’re underway and want to filter small amounts of water.
- Sawyer squeeze mini filter
The one almost everyone knows and uses. Fill up the plastic bag, attach the filter and squeeze the bag. It’s quicker than the MSR trailshot. The plastic bag does tend to wear down relatively quick. But replacements can be bought. You can also use it for your camelbag. Attach the hoses on each end and voila.
Outdoor water purifiers
You can find these in almost any pharmacy and are the most used water purifiers.
- Aquamira Drops
A tiny drop of chlorine dioxide in your water bottle does the trick. The water will taste the same, so no chlorine taste. On top of that, unlike many other water purification drops, it is effective against any virus, protozoa and bacteria.
- Steripen UV Adventurer Opti
It uses UV filter as purifying method. It is an electrical device run on battery. It is small and lightweight so it is easy to take with you on any outdoor trip.